How to compare recruitment systems and choose the right ATS or CRM
Compare recruitment systems based on your process, not a feature list. Learn how to assess an ATS, a CRM or all-in-one recruitment software properly.
A successful software choice starts with analysing your own process, so you don't pay for features you never use. Only pick a specific system type once you've mapped out the workflow, integration needs and day-to-day usability.
Comparing recruitment systems works best when you start with your own process. Look first at how candidates come in, how your team works together, and where valuable time gets lost. Only after that does it make sense to compare recruitment software and weigh up tools against each other. That way you avoid choosing based on features you never actually use in practice.
In this article you get a practical framework to put systems properly side by side, so you make a well-considered choice that fits your everyday work perfectly.
- Always start with your process, not with a random list of tools
- Decide on the type of system first: an ATS, a CRM or an all-in-one solution
- In practice, focus mainly on the workflow, ease of use and integrations
- Test the systems with your own vacancies and team members
Why comparing recruitment systems often starts with the tools too soon
Many teams start their search with terms like 'the best ATS' or look for an alternative to a tool they already know. That sounds logical, but it often creates noise. You end up comparing features without it being clear what you actually need. As a result, every system looks very complete, while in practice it does not actually fit.
In reality, recruiters often use several tools at once. Sourcing happens through LinkedIn, follow-up runs through email, and the ATS only gets filled in later in the process. This causes fragmentation. Anyone who takes comparing a recruitment system seriously therefore looks at the process first, and only then at the tooling.
Comparing recruitment systems starts with the right type of software
What is an ATS?
An Applicant Tracking System (ATS) supports the hiring process. You use it to manage candidates, vacancies and feedback centrally in one place. Teams comparing an ATS mainly pay attention to structure, reporting and collaboration within the hiring process.
What is a recruitment CRM?
A recruitment CRM focuses specifically on long-term relationships. Think of talent pools, re-engagement and client management. This type of software therefore suits agencies and commercial recruitment teams very well.
What is all-in-one recruitment software?
All-in-one recruitment software combines an ATS and a CRM. This gives you a lot of overview, but the depth on each side varies a great deal between solutions. That is why it is essential to assess carefully where the real strength of the system lies.
What to pay attention to when comparing recruitment systems in practice
When comparing recruitment systems, everything comes down to daily use. Selection criteria for recruitment software certainly help, but only if you apply them specifically to your own workflow.
Integrations and workflow
The integrations of a recruitment system determine whether your hiring process runs smoothly. Think, for example, of seamless connections with LinkedIn, your email and your calendar. If systems do not work well together, unnecessary manual work quickly builds up. Many teams discover, while mapping out the gaps between their tooling and their way of working, that the biggest bottleneck actually sits before the ATS.
Ease of use and speed
The user experience (UX) of recruitment software needs to be immediately clear. Recruiters often work under time pressure and simply do not have time to learn a complicated system from scratch. An unclear interface quickly leads to low adoption, and less structure rather than more.
Cost and realistic use
The fixed monthly price is only part of the total financial picture. So also look critically at implementation costs, the training required and any extra modules. A lot of manual work happening outside the system also makes the software considerably more expensive in the end than it first appears.
Scalability
Scalable recruitment software grows with your team without friction. What works excellently for a single recruiter is not necessarily suitable for ten users, all with different roles and different reporting needs.
Support and onboarding
Support for recruitment software partly determines how quickly you actually get value from a new system. Good, smooth onboarding and fast help with questions lead to a considerably shorter learning curve and much more efficient use.
Tip: Elvatix gets more out of every InMail credit. Higher response rates, lower cost per contact.
See how →Comparing recruitment systems: options worth putting side by side
There is no single universal best choice. The right tool always depends on your own process, your team and the current growth stage of your organisation.
Recruitee
Recruitee is a well-known ATS that puts collaboration front and centre. The system is very clear and particularly well suited to teams looking for extra structure in their hiring process. Anyone considering an alternative to Recruitee is usually after somewhat more advanced CRM functionality.
Homerun recruitment software
Homerun's recruitment software focuses strongly on simplicity and a great candidate experience. This platform works very well for smaller teams, but offers relatively little depth for genuinely complex processes.
OTYS ATS & CRM
OTYS combines both an ATS and a CRM in one extensive system. It offers a huge amount of functionality and therefore fits professional recruitment agencies well. Initial setup does take somewhat more time, though, because of the complexity of the software.
Bullhorn's recruitment CRM
Bullhorn's recruitment CRM focuses specifically on larger organisations and staffing agencies. It supports extensive commercial processes, but can quickly feel a bit heavy and cumbersome for smaller teams.
Comparing recruitment systems in 5 steps that actually fit
- Map out your current process precisely, from sourcing right through to the final placement
- Determine your most important functional requirements and priorities
- Make a focused shortlist of systems that fit this well
- Always test the software with your own vacancies and with real scenarios
- Have your whole team actively work with the system before you make a final decision
Why comparing recruitment systems does not stop at your ATS
In a huge number of teams, sourcing candidates still happens completely outside the system. Recruiters work directly in LinkedIn and keep track of follow-up somewhere separate. This quickly creates inefficiency and a real loss of overall overview. In the ATS, that information is then only actually recorded much later in the process.
In practice, we see that this front end of the process can often be organised a lot better, since outreach and follow-up are still too often handled manually. On our page about how outreach and personalisation work, you can see clearly how this specific process can be structured smartly, right alongside the systems you already have.
Teams that combine this approach effectively with their current ATS immediately get much more grip on the front end of their funnel. In these real examples from other teams you can read exactly what positive impact this has, both on speed and on the eventual follow-up of candidates.
Comparing recruitment systems means choosing based on process and growth stage
Comparing recruitment systems only works in practice if you genuinely base every choice on your own way of working. A large corporate team, after all, has completely different requirements than a small recruitment agency. That is why it always helps to first take a good look at which teams a given solution is relevant for and exactly how your own internal process is set up.
Following the right order remains hugely important here. So determine your process first, then choose the type of system that fits it, and only select the specific tool right at the end. That way you avoid, quite simply, ending up with software that does not fit your team's daily reality at all.
If you would like to talk through the best setup, feel free to get in touch with us about the ideal recruitment stack. We are happy to think along with you about the perfect division of roles between an ATS, a CRM and your sourcing strategy in your specific situation.
Frequently asked questions about comparing recruitment systems
What is the difference between comparing an ATS and comparing recruitment software in general?
Comparing an ATS is specifically about managing vacancies and candidates. Comparing recruitment software is broader and also covers CRM systems and complete all-in-one solutions.
What is the best ATS?
The absolute best choice always depends closely on your own process, your current team size and the integrations you need. There is no simple, standard answer that works for every company.
When is a recruitment CRM the best choice?
This type of software suits organisations very well that work a lot with talent pools, have recurring placements, and place a lot of value on long-term relationships with both their candidates and their clients.
Write a personal message right here
Enter a name or LinkedIn URL and get a personalised message within 30 seconds. No account needed.
Does your recruitment tool actually fit your process?
Elvatix offers an integrated platform that automates your entire workflow from sourcing to placement. Our seamless integrations and intuitive interface keep manual work off your plate.
